Alan Shearer Slams VAR Decision in Manchester United's Loss to West Ham

Newcastle United legend Alan Shearer has publicly criticized the controversial VAR decision that led to a penalty for West Ham during their match against Manchester United, which ultimately cost the Red Devils a point.

The Controversial Incident

With the match tied at 1-1, West Ham appealed for a penalty after Danny Ings fell to the ground following minimal contact from Matthijs de Ligt. Initially, referee David Coote opted not to award a penalty, allowing play to continue. However, VAR official Michael Oliver intervened, leading to a review that resulted in Coote overturning his decision and awarding a penalty. Jarrod Bowen stepped up to convert the spot kick, sealing a 2-1 victory for West Ham and leaving United reeling from their fourth loss in nine league matches.

The Premier League Match Centre later explained the decision, stating: "The referee did not award a penalty to West Ham for a challenge by De Ligt on Ings. The VAR deemed there was sufficient contact on Ings' lower leg and recommended an on-field review. The referee overturned his original decision and awarded a penalty."

Shearer’s Reaction

Shearer was vocal in his disapproval of the decision during post-match commentary, labeling it an "awful decision." He stated, "That's a terrible decision whether you like Manchester United or not, and I don't understand why Michael Oliver [VAR] got involved." His frustration echoed sentiments shared by many fans and pundits who believe VAR's intervention was unwarranted in this instance.

Despite his strong criticism of the officiating, Shearer did offer praise to West Ham and their manager, Julen Lopetegui, for their improved performance in the second half. "Well done Julen Lopetegui, because his team really were awful in that first half," he remarked, highlighting the changes made by Lopetegui that injected energy and urgency into West Ham's game. He noted, "West Ham punished Man United with good one-touch football. It's a huge day for Lopetegui."

The Bigger Picture

This defeat leaves Manchester United languishing in 14th place in the Premier League table, raising further questions about manager Erik ten Hag's position. The Red Devils have now suffered four defeats in their first nine matches, prompting discussions about the team's form and future direction.

As the controversy surrounding the penalty decision continues, Shearer's comments reflect a broader discontent with how VAR is being utilized in the Premier League, with many calling for a reevaluation of its role in officiating matches.