Why Liverpool Chose Arne Slot Over Ruben Amorim, According to Jamie Carragher
One of the main reasons for rejecting Amorim, according to Carragher, was his preference for a three-man defense, a system that contrasted with Klopp's long-established 4-3-3 formation.
Jamie Carragher has shed light on why Liverpool opted for Arne Slot over Ruben Amorim earlier this year, despite the Portuguese manager's success at Sporting CP. Amorim, now appointed as Manchester United’s new manager following Erik ten Hag's departure, was initially considered by Liverpool as a potential successor to Jurgen Klopp. However, Carragher pointed to tactical differences as a key factor in Liverpool’s eventual choice.
One of the main reasons for rejecting Amorim, according to Carragher, was his preference for a three-man defense, a system that contrasted with Klopp's long-established 4-3-3 formation. Klopp’s tactical approach, ingrained throughout Liverpool’s squad and youth teams, has created a seamless style of play that the club values deeply. Shifting to a three-man defense, Carragher suggests, would have required a significant tactical overhaul, something that could disrupt the team’s established system.
In contrast, Arne Slot’s tactical approach at Feyenoord, which aligns more closely with Klopp’s four-at-the-back strategy, made him a more suitable candidate for Liverpool. Carragher, writing for The Telegraph, noted that Slot’s preference for a traditional four-man defense would have made the transition smoother for the squad. The continuity in defensive structure under Slot was seen as beneficial for maintaining consistency across the club.
Amorim’s success with Sporting CP, including ending the club’s 19-year wait for a league title, cannot be ignored, though. His innovative use of a back three has garnered attention, and his approach might have been seen as a better fit for other clubs, particularly Manchester United, where a tactical shift could be just what the team needs to improve their season. Former United player Gary Neville has suggested that a back three might suit the Red Devils better, considering the team's defensive vulnerabilities and the attacking strength of their full-backs.
Ultimately, while Amorim’s philosophy and achievements are undeniable, Liverpool’s preference for stability and a smooth transition led them to choose Slot. Meanwhile, at Manchester United, Amorim's tactical flexibility may be just the answer to solve some of the team’s ongoing struggles.
